Splendid E-zine (splendidezine.com)
Review by Josh Kazman :: March 25, 2003

And Nothing is #1 is built upon self-absorbed lyrics spouting angsty silhouettes of melancholy dispositions and want-you-back one-liners. Lyrics like "I'm trying not to hide that I'm horrible but I am" and "I'm fine and that's what I've been telling" weigh the album down with mundane problems and emotions that don't seem worth singing about -- and when the band isn't focused on the first person, it's the second person, who is ever so dearly missed ("I'll see you in a month and maybe we'll talk about / Everything that's happened from then to now").

If you can get beyond these points, you'll find that Up Up... play some pretty good music. The EP is a nice mix of bare melodic riffs and crashing guitars, balancing angry screaming vocals along or on top of downbeat, 764-HERO-style singing. Transitions between tracks are elegant and subtle; the best instance occurs when the sluggishly relaxing "You Landed so Gracefully" slips into "I Know You'll Find Out That I'm a Geek"'s suave beat and driving melody. The harder moments are angular and edgy, revving up the unusually stylish melodies of the aforementioned songs and "Muscle, When Will I See It?".

This is a short record -- ten songs in less than 30 minutes. The music changes constantly, rarely adhering to predictable structures. Except for a few brief slips, such as "Is That a Terrible Thing to Say?"'s horribly saccharine strings, it shifts easily between faster and slower segments. If only the lyrics were as innovative as the music, and Nothing is #1 would be great.